CleanMy®Phone vs Smart Cleaner: what 1,299 reviews say

CleanMy®Phone vs Smart Cleaner: the numbers side by side

Where do CleanMy®Phone and Smart Cleaner differ most?

• CleanMy®Phone's unhappy reviewers mention the app not working or doing little roughly twice as often as Smart Cleaner's: 28.6% against 12.3% of 1–2★ reviews.
• CleanMy®Phone's unhappy reviewers mention slowness, crashes and bugs about 8 times as often as Smart Cleaner's: 12.2% against 1.6% of 1–2★ reviews.
• On having to review items one by one, CleanMy®Phone draws 3.8% of its 1–2★ reviews, while Smart Cleaner draws 0%.
• Billing, trials and cancelling is a bigger issue for Smart Cleaner (56.7% of low ratings) than for CleanMy®Phone (53.6%).
• Space that never came back is a bigger issue for CleanMy®Phone (3.5% of low ratings) than for Smart Cleaner (0.5%).

Both are compared on iPhone. CleanMy®Phone finds duplicates, similar and blurry photos, screenshots and large videos, and was previously sold as Gemini Photos; Smart Cleaner clears duplicates and unneeded files and sorts and compresses media.

Are CleanMy®Phone and Smart Cleaner improving?

CleanMy®Phone went from 3.81 stars in 2025-Q3 to 3.83 in 2026-Q3, with billing at 16.7% of its latest 1–2★ reviews. Smart Cleaner went from 2.38 stars in 2025-Q3 to 2.33 in 2026-Q1, with billing at 58.3% of its latest 1–2★ reviews.

Where are CleanMy®Phone and Smart Cleaner alike?

Their reviewers agree on ads, pop-ups and pushy screens, an ad or listing that promised something else and support that doesn't answer: on each, the two apps are within two points of each other (2.6% vs 2.7%; 4.1% vs 2.7%; 2.9% vs 1.6%). 28.2% of CleanMy®Phone's reviews are 1★ and 52% are 5★; for Smart Cleaner the split is 52.8% and 31.4%, so Smart Cleaner has noticeably more very angry reviewers.

What do happy users praise in each?

37.7% of CleanMy®Phone's 4–5★ reviews say it works, compared with 15% for Smart Cleaner. 25.2% of CleanMy®Phone's 4–5★ reviews say it is easy to use, compared with 11.5% for Smart Cleaner. 11.4% of CleanMy®Phone's 4–5★ reviews say it finds duplicates and similar shots, compared with 0.9% for Smart Cleaner.

Which is cheaper, CleanMy®Phone or Smart Cleaner?

CleanMy®Phone: App Store (US) in-app purchases from $2.99 to $39.99. Smart Cleaner: App Store (US) in-app purchases from $5.99 to $39.99. CleanMy®Phone starts lower, at $2.99 against $5.99. Billing makes up 53.6% of CleanMy®Phone's 1–2★ reviews and 56.7% of Smart Cleaner's.

What reviewers say about CleanMy®Phone and Smart Cleaner

• CleanMy®Phone: "Disappointing- does nothing to remove system storage or IOS downloads - just a photo clearance app. Not worth the money" (2★, App Store, UK, Oct 2025)
• CleanMy®Phone: "I have 27,000 photos and it is trying to upload them onto the app but it keeps on crashing repeatedly, making it unusable" (1★, App Store, UK, Aug 2019)
• Smart Cleaner: "Got this as a “free app” but cash has been taken from my account & this app simply does not work!😡" (1★, App Store, UK, Dec 2025)
• Smart Cleaner: "Not impressed. Everytime it does a cleanup it still says I have only feed up 1%. I want my money back!!" (2★, App Store, US, Oct 2025)

Picked from the the app not working or doing little and slowness, crashes and bugs themes, where the two differ most.

Should you choose CleanMy®Phone or Smart Cleaner?

On ratings alone, CleanMy®Phone is the safer bet on the evidence here, with 25.9% fewer 1–2★ reviews. If the app not working or doing little is what worries you most, Smart Cleaner has the better record on it.